Amazon FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) and FBM (Fulfillment by Merchant) represent two distinct approaches to handling inventory and order fulfillment on the Amazon platform.

• Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is a fulfillment method on Amazon in which sellers send their products to Amazon’s fulfillment centers, where they are stored, packed, and shipped to customers once orders are received. Amazon then takes care of customer service and returns and even offers Prime shipping benefits. This method allows sellers to leverage Amazon’s extensive infrastructure and delegate logistics responsibilities.
• Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) is a fulfillment method on Amazon that requires sellers to manage their own inventory, storage, packing, and shipping processes. Sellers retain full control over their products throughout the entire fulfillment process, allowing for more flexibility in branding, packaging, and customer interactions. This method requires more hands-on management but also offers greater control over costs and the customer experience.

When deciding on a fulfillment method for selling products on Amazon, several critical factors demand careful consideration to ensure the most effective strategy for your business:

• Expenses and fees: A comprehensive evaluation of costs and fees associated with each fulfillment method is essential for determining the overall cost-effectiveness of your selling strategy. Amazon FBA sellers are required to pay FBA fees for products to be shipped through Amazon’s fulfillment network. The FBA fees cover selecting, packing, and shipping the items to the customer. 

On the other hand, Amazon FBM sellers don’t need to pay FBA fees, but they still need to budget for the costs associated with handling and shipping their products. This includes labor costs, product packaging, storage, and the actual cost of shipping the product. If these expenses outweigh the fees associated with having Amazon manage fulfillment, the seller may choose Amazon FBA.

• Size and weight of the product: Your products’ physical attributes significantly impact your fulfillment strategy. Larger or heavier items may incur higher storage and shipping costs, making it essential to assess how your product characteristics align with the fulfillment options available through Amazon FBA and FBM. Amazon’s fee structure and logistics benefit FBA sellers with small, lightweight products that sell quickly.
• Control of customer experience: The level of control you desire over the customer experience is crucial in selecting the correct fulfillment method. FBA provides standardized packaging, shipping, and customer service, ensuring order consistency. Alternatively, FBM grants sellers more control over branding, packaging, and customer communication, enabling a more personalized experience. FBA can be the best choice if you prefer a more detached approach, particularly when handling problems like consumer returns. 
• Inventory turnover rate: Understanding your inventory turnover rate is essential for optimizing storage costs and minimizing the risk of stockouts or overstock situations. Amazon calculates storage fees based on inventory duration in fulfillment centers. Extended storage incurs additional charges, including aged inventory surcharges after 180 days, adversely affecting seller metrics and inventory management capabilities. FBA’s dynamic storage and fulfillment capabilities may be advantageous for products with high turnover rates, whereas FBM allows for more precise control over inventory levels and storage costs. 
• Shipping and Delivery Speed:  Assess the capabilities of each fulfillment method in terms of shipping speed, order tracking, and delivery reliability to ensure your logistics operations align with customer expectations and marketplace standards. For newcomers to Amazon who are selling without established fulfillment logistics, opting for Amazon FBA is advisable due to the time-consuming nature of picking, packing, and shipping products independently. This allows sellers to concentrate on essential business-building tasks. However, those integrating Amazon as a new sales channel with existing logistics should evaluate whether Amazon FBA can offer cost savings, particularly for high-turnover products.
• Seller Feedback: Your seller feedback and ratings on Amazon can directly influence buyer trust and purchasing decisions. As Amazon manages most of the processes associated with fulfilling FBA products, FBA sellers don’t need to worry as much about seller feedback. If they receive unfavorable feedback, FBA sellers can ask for negative feedback to be erased. Meanwhile, FBM sellers need to pay more attention to the state of the products they provide, how quickly they deliver products, and how they handle communications.
• Prime Badge: Utilizing Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) automatically grants products Prime shipping eligibility, accompanied by the recognizable Prime badge, appealing to over 200 million Amazon Prime members worldwide who seek expedited 1-2 day delivery. This advantage underscores FBA’s appeal over Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM). However, FBM sellers can also access Prime shipping through Seller-Fulfilled Prime, providing an alternative route to cater to Prime members’ preferences while maintaining control over fulfillment processes.

Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) is the optimal choice under several circumstances. If you prioritize controlling customer interactions and already have robust customer service practices, FBM aligns well with your objectives. Additionally, if your product offerings consist of oversized or heavy items, FBM allows for more flexibility in managing these products. An established logistics infrastructure further supports using FBM, enabling efficient order fulfillment processes. Moreover, if you can effectively manage the costs associated with self-fulfillment and your inventory turnover rate is gradual, FBM offers a suitable fulfillment solution.

Nevertheless, Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) presents compelling advantages under specific circumstances. If your product offerings consist of small and lightweight items, FBA provides a streamlined fulfillment solution optimized for such products. If you are comfortable relinquishing control over customer interactions to Amazon and prefer having Amazon manage customer service, FBA aligns with your preferences. Additionally, if your inventory turnover rate is rapid, FBA’s dynamic storage and fulfillment capabilities can efficiently manage fluctuating demand. FBA is particularly beneficial if you lack established logistics infrastructure, as it offers a comprehensive fulfillment solution. If self-fulfillment results in higher expenses, FBA will provide a cost-effective alternative by leveraging Amazon’s infrastructure and economies of scale.

The most popular product categories for Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) and Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) might change depending on seller choices, consumer demand, and market trends. Still, a few categories regularly do well with both fulfillment strategies:

Top FBA product categories:

• Electronics: Including consumer electronics, accessories, and gadgets.
• Kitchen and Home: Including gadgets, tableware, and interior design.
• Health and Personal Care: Personal care items, vitamins, and supplements.
• Games and Toys: Including puzzles, board games, and educational toys.
• Books: Including both hard copy and electronic books.
• Clothes and Accessories: Including clothing, shoes, and accessories.
• Beauty: Including products for makeup, skincare, and grooming.
• Sports and Outdoors: Sports supplies, outdoor gear, and fitness equipment.
• Baby products: Including necessities for the nursery, diapers, and baby food.
• Pet supplies: Including food, toys, and grooming supplies.

Top product categories for FBM:

• Handcrafts: Handmade products crafted by craftsmen/artisans.
• Vintage and Collectibles: Including rare or vintage items, collectibles, and antiques.
• Unique Gifts: Including novelty gifts, quirky gadgets, and specialty products.
• Customized Products: Personalized products tailored to individual preferences.
• Specialty Foods: Including gourmet foods, snacks, and specialty ingredients.
• Local Products: Locally sourced or region-specific products.
• Niche or Specialty Products: Including products that appeal to particular interests, hobbies, or groups of people.
• Arts and Crafts Supplies: Including crafting materials, tools, and DIY kits.
• Home Products and Decor: Handcrafted or artisanal home decorations and furnishings.
• Home Services: Services such as home repairs, installations, and consultations.

These categories represent popular options for sellers on Amazon. Product categories for FBA and FBM ultimately rely on factors like seller competence, target market, and competitive landscape. When choosing product categories for Amazon fulfillment, sellers must conduct in-depth market research and consider their resources and strengths.

In general, fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) typically requires less time for sellers to handle than fulfillment by merchant (FBM). With FBA, sellers send their inventory to Amazon’s fulfillment centers, where Amazon takes care of storage, packing, shipping, and customer service. This means that sellers don’t have to worry about managing inventory, packing orders, or handling shipping logistics themselves, which can save significant time and resources.

On the other hand, with FBM, sellers are responsible for managing their inventory, packing orders, and shipping them directly to customers. This can be more time-consuming, especially for sellers with larger orders or complex shipping requirements. Additionally, sellers using FBM must handle customer inquiries and returns themselves, which can add to the time required to manage orders.

Overall, FBA is the more time-efficient option for sellers who value convenience and want to streamline their fulfillment process. However, the optimal fulfillment method depends on various factors, including the seller’s business model, sales volume, product type, and operational capabilities.

If you’ve ever considered starting an Amazon business but are unsure of where to start, you’re welcome to book your Free Consultation with us, or get in touch here: [email protected]